Easy Heart Cookies {With Cake Mix} (2024)

Published: Jan 19, 2021 · Modified: Mar 19, 2023 by Abeer Rizvi · This post may contain affiliate links · 64 Comments

Easy heart cookies recipe, homemade with simple ingredients. Starts off with red velvet cake mix. These cut out sugar cookies hold their shape with no spreading.

These are the perfect way to say "I love you" this season! Make them for your family or let the kids decorate them or give them as gifts to family and friends. There is no wrong way to share the love! These Valentine's Day Cookies {Love Letter Cookies} and Easy Love Cake are two other fun ideas. If you are still stuck on ideas, be sure to browse these Pink Desserts {Valentine's Day Dessert}. There has to be some treat in there to inspire you.

Want to Save This Recipe?

Enter your email & I'll send it to your inbox.Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!

By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from CakeWhiz

How to make heart cookies?

1. Mix egg and butter-Until combined.
2. Add cake mix- And mix again.
3. Cover- And chill dough.
4. Roll dough- Between two sheets of wax paper.
5. Cut out shapes- Using a cookie cutter.
6. Remove excess dough- From around the shapes.
7. Bake- Until crisp along the edges.
8. Decorate-With royal icing or melted white chocolate and sanding sugar.

Variations for decorated heart shaped cookies

Decorate with marshmallow fondant- It can be Homemade Marshmallow Fondant or store-bought fondant. Both work well.

Decorate with icing that dries hard- The two choices are Royal Icing and Glace Icing.

Try soft frosting- Such as this Best Sugar Cookie Frosting. You won't be able to stack cookies, but they will taste great.

Try other sprinkles and seasonal sugar decorations- Such as these Fondant Flowers or Royal icing Flowers.

Valentine sugar cookies /heart sugar cookies- Use my Cut Out Chocolate Sugar Cookie Recipe or these Classic Cut Out Sugar Cookies.

Dip the cookies in melted chocolate- Dip only halfway for an elegant decoration.

Decorate with nuts or coconut- Nuts should be finely chopped and if using coconut, use shredded or desiccated versions.

Add extracts- Such as coconut, caramel, cherry, almond for a unique flavor profile.

Add zests- Such as lemon, lime or orange.

Make sandwich cookies- By adding jam or American Buttercream Frosting in the middle of 2 cookies.

Use other cake mix flavors- Instead of red velvet, use chocolate, lemon or yellow mix for different flavors.

Tips and techniques for Valentine's Day cookies

Chill dough- Because this makes it easier to handle. Don't skip this step! Most importantly, it prevents the cookies from spreading too much while baking and helps hold their shape.

Don't over mix- Because that will make your cookies fall flat and become dense.

Only work with half the dough at a time- Keep the other half in the fridge so that is stays cold and remains easy to work with.

Roll dough between two sheets of wax paper or parchment paper- Make sure you are leaving enough space between each cookie so that there is enough space for them to expand during baking.

Cool cookies completely- Before removing them from the tray so that they don't break when you remove them.

Make sure the egg and butter at room temperature- Because this allows them to blend properly.

There is no milk or water in this recipe- Do not add those ingredients or else the dough will become very sticky.

Sift cake mix- Because that removes any lumps, resulting in a smooth dough.

Use unsalted butter- Because that prevents these cookies from becoming too salty.

Don't decorate warm cookies- They must cool completely because if they are warm, the decorations can melt and become sticky.

The number of total cookies from this recipe will vary- Because that depends on the size of your cutter and the thickness in which you roll out your dough.

Storage

Room temperature- Store leftovers in a cookie jar for up to 3 days.

Refrigerate- They can also be stored in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 1 week.

Freeze- In a sealed container for up to 1 month. Thaw at room temperature.

More heart designs

You can also make 8 other designs with just 1 heart cutter. Use fondant or royal icing or glace icing.

1. Strawberries
2. Swimwear
3. Love Bugs
4. Corset
5. Bride's dress
6. Tuxedo
7. Santa Claus
8. Web of Love

More Valentine's Day desserts

• How To Make A Flower Cupcake Bouquet
• How To Make Buttercream Ruffle Cake
• Valentine's Day Cupcakes
• Valentine's Day Dessert Table

Recipe